Ive seen alot of throwdowns with everyones "idea" of who the top 10 are and in order. Ive taken the time out of my busy day at work to grace you guys with the real list.(j/k) In order by #'s... Not the most popular or who won the most SB's. Not by who has the best leadership or any other crap.....
1) Peyton Manning----Surprise, surprise!
2) Drew Brees --- This may be a surprise but he was 1st in yds, 2nd in rating and 3rd in TD's
3) Carson Palmer --- 2nd in TD's.....5th in total yds....
4) Tom Brady --- Calm down BoSox Nation..... like i said, im goin by the #'s, not the intangibles. 7th in yds...4th in tds...9th in rating.... Your lucky he got this high
5) Marc Bulger --- 3rd in yds.....6th in tds and 7th in passer rating 6) Jon Kitna --- This might be a surprise to some also but 4th in yds and 9th in tds
7) Brett Favre --- 6th in yds and thats alot considering the circumstances in Green Bay!
8) Phillip Rivers --- 8th in yds....8th in tds....8th in rating....nuff said
9) Tony Romo --- Only started 10 games but averaged over 290 yds and almost 2 td's per game. More impressive is the fact that his rating was 95.1.....which is good for 5th in the NFL
10) This is the only one that can change... I got Rolisberger here but only cause he led the other guy's i had picked out in total yds
The other guys you can substitue in at 10 are Chad P, JP Losman, Rex and a couple other guys
Daniella Sarahyba
Larisa & Marisa Coy
Championship Game Fans
BCS National Championship
Comments (12) Add A Comment
You better add Steve McNair to one of the guys you can substitute with for the 10 spot especially if you have Pennington and Grossman
GoatHCW
Nottingham , MD
Total Comments (1284)
WHERE IS VINNY TESTERVERDE?!?!?!?!?!
AND AARON BROOKS?!?!?!?!?!?!
WHAT THE HELL?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
Coletrain
Total Comments (10918)
Could one about Favre but the rest of your list is bad
packer* BS
Total Comments (93)
my list is by the #'s..... #'s dont lie or have emtional ties....or have a favorite
Goodell: Bills =…
Nfl Headquarters, NY
Total Comments (6486)
hey check out my throwdown about brady being better than peyton. if your a true pats fan you vote.
Elway4Prez
Glendale , AZ
Total Comments (2527)
actually, i think this is a pretty good list
billdathrill
Austin , TX
Total Comments (44)
Based on stats (as you said), those are very good, very honest rankings. People are so high on the "Tom Brady Dynasty", the seem to have forgotten he hasn't won since 2004.
Lifer: Metallica…
Total Comments (9861)
Yeah I agree. It's based on stats, so it makes sense to have Brady at 4. People are so high on his leadership and everything but don't notice his numbers are not the best. If anyone is interested, they should read my blog on the top 10 college qbs.
erwin: Back Again.
The Big House, MI
Total Comments (2186)
Do number say who do they have to throw to... I mean i know it's based on stats but he had Jabar Gaffney and Rache Caldwell...They wouldn't start on Florida last season. If you considered the circumstances for Brett Farve you should for Tom Brady
And Mr. Gooddell please don't ground Pac-man any longer. He going to be on his best behavoir if you let him comeback.
11IsDaNew16
Fishers , IN
Total Comments (316)
Also I know it's by numbers but would you put Marino ahead of say Montana or Elway.
11IsDaNew16
Fishers , IN
Total Comments (316)
Great list if we were trying to predict who to pick for last season's fantasy league. Not so good if you look forward to this season. Chad P or Rex over D Mac? Have your list has to be justified by: "only played x games, had noone to throw to..."
oneadam10
San Diego , CA
Total Comments (6)
make that "half your list justified by...:
oneadam10
San Diego , CA
Total Comments (6)
Comment
Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.