Views
907
Comments
39

If you were in this last time, you might remember how I did the seedings. For the first round, I subtracted the number of losses from the number of wins. After the first round, I seed by the margins of victory. So here's how the seedings are for the first round:

(1) NCshv David

(2) Denis 24

(3) DetroitFan

(4) efbasketball

(5) Phillyman

(6) BSchwartz

(7) Ed Reeds #1 Fan (I think that's his name....just Ed Reed if you can't find him)

(8)Duquesne Cap #NR

(9) Broncos4Ever

(10) bigdleech

(11) Rodclo

(12) Mr. News

(13) JonesyPB

(14) Cheezhead

(15) enderandrew

(16) Nolan Adair

(17) Esco

(18) i before e

(19) DA MASTA

(20) Heartbreak Kid

(21) dudeman

(22) Crappo

(23) dyhardbasbalfan (last tourneys low seed, won in first round)

(24) Super Squirrel

 

Those are the seedings, here are the matchups:

(1) NCshv David vs. (24) Super Squirrel : What is more likely, 19-0 Patriots or 0-16 'Phins?: Super Squirrel wins, 7-5 (2).

(2) Denis 24 vs. (23) dyhardbasbalfan: NFC Pro Bowl Roster: Denis is forfeited from the tourney; took too long to reply. Dyhard wins. You can finish the td, but no effect on tourney. (0)

(3) DetroitFan vs. (22) Crappo: AFC Pro Bowl Roster: DetroitFan is forfeited due to a week away from the site coming up. (0)

(4) efbasketball vs. (21) dudeman: Should the 'Skins have to change their name/logo?: efbasketball is forfeited, just like half of the field. dudeman moves on. (0)

(5) Phillyman vs. (20) Heartbreak Kid: Favre record least likely to be broken.: Phillyman wins, 15-5 (10)

(6) BSchwartz vs. (19)DA MASTA: Should Spygate taint the Pats?: DA MASTA, 12-10 (2)

(7) Ed Reed vs. (18) i before e: What's easier for a head coach, NCAA to NFL or other way?: Ed Reed won, 13-9 (4).

(8) Duquesne Cap vs. (17) Esco: Most overrated HoF: Dusquesne Cap by forfeit, 8-4 (4).

(9) Broncos4Ever vs. (16) Nolan Adair: Biggest '07 Draft Bust: Broncos4Ever is forfeited.

(10) bigdleech vs. (15) enderandrew: 4-3 or 3-4 defense?: bigdleech advances because enderandrew didn't accept his challenge. (0)

(11) Rodclo vs. (14) Cheezhead: If the Patriots don't win the Super Bowl, who will?: Cheezhead won, 14-17 (3).

(12) Mr. News vs. (13) JonesyPB: Will Michael Vick return to the NFL?: Jonesy wins, 12-9 (3)

 

 

RULES: 1) Better seed makes first argument

               2) 24 hours to reply to argument

               3) IMPORTANT ONE!!!: If you don't like your topic, send me or your opponent a fanmail of the new topic, if he agrees, that's the new topic, if not, use the topic given. Please inform me of TD switches!

               4) Label all throwdowns as: NFL Nation TD Tourney (Round #): (Topic)

               5) No voting until each person makes at least one argument.

 

PLEASE POST TOPICS IN THE GROUP MESSAGE BOARD (MORE THAN ONE WOULD BE NICE). THANK YOU.

 

 

 

November 23, 2007  11:14 AM ET

24 People!!!!

Wow!!!!!

Cool!!!!!

November 23, 2007  11:18 AM ET

Amazing!!!!

Awesome!!! :-)

November 23, 2007  11:27 AM ET

the first two are better matchups than anyone would think...

November 23, 2007  11:35 AM ET

Yeah, I think they will be pretty good.

November 23, 2007  11:49 AM ET

Very nice.

November 23, 2007  01:46 PM ET

I think gu3 would be the 24th seed if he was in this...then win his TD...

November 23, 2007  01:50 PM ET

I don't know, it would be close.

November 23, 2007  03:07 PM ET

when do we face off

November 24, 2007  10:34 AM ET

When we get enough topics.

November 24, 2007  01:04 PM ET

I think we have enough topics...

November 24, 2007  01:05 PM ET

enderandrew posted like 30 of them...

November 24, 2007  03:37 PM ET

54-21=33. Not bad.

November 24, 2007  07:41 PM ET

wait, how did you determine ties?

November 24, 2007  09:24 PM ET

For ties in TD's, I put the TD on the group poll, and the Nation members vote on the arguments.

November 24, 2007  09:38 PM ET

Good luck Denis24.

November 24, 2007  09:46 PM ET

I just joined this group and want a piece of the next tourney. My TD record is 54-21-4.

November 24, 2007  09:58 PM ET

I meant like if one person was 50-15 and another was 65-30

November 24, 2007  09:59 PM ET

for their seedings

November 24, 2007  10:22 PM ET

Cheezhead, I've challenged you already. Although I forgot to title it properly, as usual.

The rest of you can check it out here: http://www.fannation.com/throwdowns/show/80924

 
November 25, 2007  09:47 AM ET

Cassidy, we'll start a new one right after this one.

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Start Your Own Blog

Start Now
Check out our new Community,Groups, and Fans pages!

Stub Hub

The 2008 schedule has been released. Search for tickets!

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Vikings in market for QB?
    Views
    22130
    Comments
    1379
  2. 2
    How will Phillies replace Romero?
    Views
    2060
    Comments
    1130
  3. 3
    Hal Steinbrenner to Brewers: Mind your own business
    Views
    10791
    Comments
    308
  4. 4
    Maualuga apologizes to Erin Andrews
    Views
    18246
    Comments
    103
  5. 5
    Mavs-Raptors blockbuster in works?
    Views
    22780
    Comments
    97

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Kuster - I'm back!
  2. 2
    bcoltrinari
  3. 3
    Epoch1
  4. 4
    Dyhard is Mason Crosby
  5. 5
    Homey Deez

Message Boards

  1. NFL > New England Patriots

    The End of Mr. Brady
    Views
    961
    Replies
    4
  2. NFL > Kansas City Chiefs

    Chiefs Ownership / New GM Hire
    Views
    496
    Replies
    5
  3. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Ohio St. Fans, in Mourning,…
    Views
    464
    Replies
    64

Blogs