Jacob Luft
::
11 months ago
:: 49030 views
On Tuesday night Arizona lost 14-5 to Florida in a game that was not as close as the score indicated. After one of the many pitching changes D'backs manager Bob Melvin had to make, a Marlins TV announcer said, "Melvin hasn't had many nights like this."
Uh, yes he has.
More than two-thirds of the way into the season, the biggest conundrum in baseball has to be the Diamondbacks and how they have managed to lead the National League in wins despite getting taken to the woodshed on a regular basis. Tuesday's rout was just the latest example. On Aug. 2 they lost to the Padres 11-0, and a couple of days before that they gave up two touchdowns in a shutout loss to the Braves.
The blowouts have become so common -- Arizona has allowed double-digit runs in losses 13 times this season -- that the D'backs, despite being 14 games over .500, have been outscored by a healthy margin (30 runs). Going strictly by run differential (or Pythagorean record), the D'backs should have a 57-63 record. Instead, they are 67-53 and sitting in the catbird's seat in the NL West.
That means Arizona is playing 10 games above its run differential, which is unusual but not unheard of (the 2004 Yankees played 12 games above their run differential). The only other team close to the D'backs in this regard is Seattle, another Cinderella contender, which is plus-6. (The Mariners' unlikely success was covered ably recently by Fungoes writer Cliff Corcoran.)
The point of looking at Pythag records isn't necessarily to rule on a team being a fluke or a legit contender. It's more of a model that can serve to tell you some things about a team. For example, one of the tenets of Pythag theory is that the truly good teams win close games and blowouts. They have enough talent to simply overpower teams sometimes. Here are the records of the six current division leaders in one-run games and blowouts (5-plus runs):
Boston Red Sox