- Views
- 14
- Comments
- 17
- August 27, 2008 10:51 AM ET
- Share
Goodell: Nov 4 is the day said 08/27, 11:12 AM
Why would you want to lighten his workload?
Grant Played in 15 games last season and stared 7. In that time frame he only had 188 carries and averaged 12.5 carries per game. He had a whoping 5.1 per carry to boot......Now I know he only started 7 games, so the 12.5 per game might be a little off.
But If I had a RB that could get me 5.1 per carry, the last thing I would do is lighten his workload. I would ride that RB all the way till his wheels fall off.
Not to mention you have an UNPROVEN QB in Rodgers....Im not saying he sucks, Im not saying he's great...Just unproven.
In the real world DJ, there is absolutley NO WAY on earth that the Pack can lighten his workload
Lets say Rodgers does turn out to be a dud......The Packers D and rushing game is good enough to win them a few games all by themselves. Why would you want to take wins away from your team when you have a clear starting caliber RB on your roster?
djroxalot said 08/27, 11:47 AM
Good luck Goodell, always fun
http://www.fannation.com/truth_and_rumors/view/63612
Meaning they dont want Grant to be the next Larry Johnson, Goody
They might want Grant to get 18-20 carries but have another back get 8-10 carries as most of the NFL is going with a nice duo at the RB position......
I guarantee if you give Grant 18-20 carries he wont be averaging 5.1ypc since he isnt the lightning quick back some are......He would be a solid 4.5ypc rusher with more carries.......
Look at Joseph Addai, he averaged 4.6ypc first half of the season and 3.4ypc 2nd half of the season because they didnt have a reliable 2nd string backup......He didnt have a 100 yard game the last 8 games of the season.......
Goodell: Nov 4 is the day said 08/27, 12:34 PM
"Meaning they dont want Grant to be the next Larry Johnson, Goody
They might want Grant to get 18-20 carries but have another back get 8-10 carries as most of the NFL is going with a nice duo at the RB position......"
Ok....Considering Grant averaged 12.5 carries, his work load would have to increase by almost 40% to reach the 18-20 carry mark. I totally agree that he shouldnt be used to the effect that LJ does, but if you limit a guys carries....You also limit the success of the team
If winning games takes Grant getting 18-20 carries per game, then they should do it
If winning games takes Grant 25-28 carries per game, then they should do it. The Packers are not in the NFL to be a good team in a lousy division. Im pretty sure they have the full intention of making and winning the SB, just like every other team in the NFL
When your RB breaks the 20 carry mark in a game, that speaks volumes for all the in game stats. Like ball control.....3rd down conversions.....Your RB doest get 20 carries per game unless you convert on 3rd. YOu also dont win games unless you convert on 3rd down
But anyways...For the sake of the TD: If Grant gets 18-20 carries per, thats a increease
djroxalot said 08/27, 05:07 PM
So you think they should replicate what Tomlin did with Parker????
Run him till his wheels fall off????
Not a smart move at all
"If winning games takes Grant 25-28 carries per game, then they should do it. The Packers are not in the NFL to be a good team in a lousy division. Im pretty sure they have the full intention of making and winning the SB, just like every other team in the NFL."
Come on Goody your Bills have a guy like Lynch and you know the value of having 2 backs to share the load......
Larry Johnson might well be done because he has been run into the ground, 336 carries and 416......What happened the season after those 416 carries????
158 for 559 yards and a 3.5 avg
McCarthy knows life expectancy of a RB and isnt trying to do that
Goodell: Nov 4 is the day said 08/28, 12:41 PM
"So you think they should replicate what Tomlin did with Parker???? "
Parker is a completely different kind of back than Grant. Parker is a physical, power back that only cuts when he has to. Grant is more of an elusive back, as opposed to a power back. Grant doesnt look for contact like Parker does
"Come on Goody your Bills have a guy like Lynch and you know the value of having 2 backs to share the load"
Your right, I do. But the Bills also have a very formidable back up in Fred Jackson who averaged 5.2 YPC and 8.6 per REC.
If you look at Brandon Jackson's numbers, they are 3.6 per carry and 8.1 per REC
Those number dont spell production from Brandon Jackson, so what in the world would the Pack be thinking to get him more carries? Brandon Jackson is not the back up that Fred Jackson is......I dont expect the Packers to run him into the ground like the Chiefs did. The chiefs offense was clearly lacking any kind of passing threat outside of Tony G. On the other hand, there are 3-4 good WR's in GB. Grant should get 20 carries per game, which comes out to 320 touches. Now, thats almost 100 less touches than LJ had.....300 carries is about average for a starting RB
Leaderboard
| Fan | W | L | T | Win % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | YODA | 46 | 3 | 2 | 92.2% |
| 2 | Porkins: You're all my dupes | 155 | 14 | 1 | 91.5% |
| 3 | Detroit... | 132 | 9 | 8 | 91.3% |
| 4 | The Ram | 149 | 17 | 4 | 88.8% |
| 5 | Baun-de... | 61 | 7 | 2 | 88.6% |
| 6 | FoosBal... | 82 | 12 | 2 | 86.5% |
| 7 | Hyped78 | 128 | 19 | 5 | 85.9% |
| 8 | PhillyE... | 75 | 11 | 4 | 85.6% |
| 9 | Dookie: Here We Go Steelers | 119 | 19 | 8 | 84.2% |
| 10 | [The] Coach | 103 | 18 | 5 | 83.7% |
Web's Best Blogs
-
James Mirtle
Decision '09: The all-star campaigns you haven't heard of
pimg src="http://assets.sbnation.com/imported_assets/34996/asg2009_big_medium_medium.jpg"…
-
With Leather
Weekend picks: ?get it on?
We pick the winners of the weekends biggest matchups every Friday, using an irrefutable sports…
-
Big League Stew
Even Chicago grade schoolers don't want Soriano leading off
Back in Chicago for a self-described mini-vacation of shopping and eating, Lou Piniella stopped…
Truth & Rumors
MOST POPULAR
-
1
T.O. frustrated with Cowboys offense
- Views
- 14134
- Comments
- 1593
-
2
Would Red Sox dare to shop Big Papi?
- Views
- 11468
- Comments
- 1277
-
3
Notre Dame nixes students' recruiting plot
- Views
- 8787
- Comments
- 86
-
4
Red Sox, Tigers talking deal
- Views
- 3470
- Comments
- 79
-
5
Agent: Ocho Cinco's future in owner's hands
- Views
- 7514
- Comments
- 77
Most Active Users
Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns
Message Boards
-
NCAAF > General NCAAF
The love for USC had died
- Views
- 403
- Replies
- 69
-
NCAAF > General NCAAF
The most anticipated game.
- Views
- 84
- Replies
- 7
-
NCAAF > General NCAAF
Gameday Predictions: Texas…
- Views
- 60
- Replies
- 3




Jullie Henderson
Jeisa Chiminazzo

Comments (17) Add A Comment
I think that Brandon Jackson is going to push Grant for playing time so I don't think there is much of an arguement here.
boltsfan
Norfolk , NE
Total Comments (277)
^ Maybe, but he hasn't exactly been tearing it up during the preseason.
TheSportsGuy.
Espn Hq, SP
Total Comments (1224)
There were trade rumors around Brandon Jackson at the end of last season cause he couldnt pull his own weight
Goodell: Nov 4 is…
Total Comments (6314)
HE WAS A FREAKIN ROOKIE, Goody
djroxalot
Total Comments (15498)
NFL is faster than college........
djroxalot
Total Comments (15498)
Um.....The Packers have a better line than Buffalo and Lynch still dominated, as a FREAKIN ROOKIE.
Grant is better than Jackson....Thats all there is to it
Goodell: Nov 4 is…
Total Comments (6314)
you have an equal chance of getting hurt per each carry
so if you do 12 instead of 18 you are still as likely to get hurt in the 12 you get as opposed to the 6 you dont, if you are calling the play and handing him the ball ist he best shot at a productive play then hand him the ball, if handing him the ball is not what you feel is your best shot at a productive play then dont, any other consideration is stupid
Frank Pentangelli
Total Comments (4904)
no way they should lessen his load... i agree with goodell on this one. with rodgers being unproven if they control the ball it will make it that much easier for rodgers to be effective.
b-dawk
Lakeland, FL
Total Comments (652)
No. They should NOT lessen his load. Unless Jackson shows that he can hold his ground.
PackersLP21
Titletown, WI
Total Comments (13310)
They are not going to lighten his workload. You have Aaron Rodgers starting, and two backups with no NFL experience, plus Brandon Jackson doesn't look capable of taking snaps away from Grant.
Nope. If anything he's going to get more carries.
Vote to Goodell.
J. HOVA: DEVILS…
Brooklyn, NY
Total Comments (13835)
By the way: Good comeback to DJ's statement by bringing up Marshawn Lynch.
Also, Grant wasn't a rookie last season. He signed with the Giants practice squad back in 2005. Last season was actually his third in the League.
J. HOVA: DEVILS…
Brooklyn, NY
Total Comments (13835)
Leaning left here
FoosBall...Licensed…
Total Comments (1966)
run him till he can't run no more.
And LJ's drop off had to do with an injury and going from having one of the best OLines in the game, to one of the worst.
rstowe
Newport News , VA
Total Comments (23815)
I don't think they should run him until his wheels fall off, but they should run him until Rodgers is more comfortable running the offense.
dp169
Dalzell, SC
Total Comments (2506)
Arguments a bit better to the right...voting that way.
Zapp Brannigan
Total Comments (849)
<-----------------------------------------------------------
Ny
Seaside Park, NJ
Total Comments (17662)
Comment
Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.