FanNation - The Republic of Sport

I think its Montana but I will wait.

Either way... saying Montana isnt crazy dave lol hes 1 or 2.

Rice - Montana was the main reason the niners won the SBs even though Rice won one without him I know ,i know that "other" QB was Steve Younge

But...

Jerry Rice is the best WR ever to play the game hands down while Montana might be the best QB ever. Since Rice is definitly the best at what he did and Joe Cool is a maybe I give left the adcantage

Montana. Receiver is an overrated position, and not near as important as QB. A good QB makes his receivers good.

Look what happened to Randy Moss when he got Tom Brady

Haven't decided which way I'm leaning yet.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Well then you aren't leaning at all.

Yeah, make a decision Dancing Gavin.

Like this: Joe Montana.

Agrippa, I am a new member here and sent you an introductory fanmail which you ignored. Can you really afford to do that in a community where you rely on the goodwill of voters?

seems like splitting hairs to me. other franchises would kill to have two greats like this to chose from. don't think you would go wrong with either choice. my choice would be Rice though as he did the same with diffrent QB's and had a longer career. Rice is the greatest reciever ever there is no debate on that, Joe is in the discussion for QB's and not the clear cut winner at his position.

Remember, Joe Montana led the Cheif to the AFC chapmionship game at the end of his career, on o team that, without him, would have trouble making the playoffs. Rice lost big in a SB with Oakland on a team that would have made the SB without him, but might not done as well. Montana at the end of his career made a bigger impact than Rice at the end of his.

Montana won 2 SB's without Rice or any HOF reciever. Rice had Young, a hall worthy QB, passing to win to win 1 SB. That shows that Montana is better than Young, but not much else because WR's don't have as much control over the gam as WR's do.

Agrippa, I am a new member here and sent you an introductory fanmail which you ignored. Can you really afford to do that in a community where you rely on the goodwill of voters?

John Joe | 09/02/08, 03:20 AM
Report Offensive Comment

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^'
What is that even supposed to mean? I rely on objective sports fans to read the title then the arguments and make an objective vote based on arguments. Any other methodology would be inconsequential for my whole reason being here.
I hardly even read my mail.

Agrippa.

John Joe = Cassidy 2.0.

Remember, Joe Montana led the Cheif to the AFC chapmionship game at the end of his career, on o team that, without him, would have trouble making the playoffs.

GaretJax is Richard Rahl |

You are WRONG- they were a 10 win team the season before with DAVE KREIG at QB and the year before that with STEVE DEBERG

don;t act like Montana came to the 2008 Dolphins and lead them to 15-1

and not only did Montana join that team but so did MARCUS ALLEN

Montana- clutch in big games and the QB that everyone wants in a SB game. He should have retired but his years with the niners were amazing.

Pimp slap with that last comment, David.

Arguments are stronger from David

This is a good throwdown with solid arguements from both sides,Agrippa brought his a game Dave.

I would go with montana but best 49er would be Rice records that will go untouched and super bowl rings with 2 different QB's,Joe has the rings but he don't have the records so at the end of Brady's career will he be better than Joe? Good Comparision though 2 great QB's but Rice goes untouched in the wideout position.